Should I invest with Charles Schwab or Vanguard?
Trading costs and commissions
Charles Schwab is a discount broker with service, education, trading tools and research that put it in the top tier of investment firms. With the integration of TD Ameritrade, including that firm's highly recognized Thinkorswim platform, Schwab has established itself as the broker to beat.
Specifically, Charles Schwab does not permit automatic systematic investment or withdrawal into Vanguard (or Dimensional Fund Advisors) mutual funds. Although Schwab does permit these funds to be held and traded on its platform, it charges investors a $45 commission to purchase or sell.
If you buy directly through Vanguard, you may benefit from lower fees, better customer service, and additional product research. Buying a Vanguard fund through a broker may involve commissions, loads, or other charges that are imposed by the broker, and not Vanguard directly—although this is not always the case.
- Relatively high minimum investment requirements for many fund options.
- Higher-than-average per-contract options fee.
- Slow process to open an account.
- No trading platform for active traders.
- No fractional shares of stocks or ETFs.
Trading costs and commissions
For mutual funds, Vanguard is significantly cheaper, while options traders would save money with Charles Schwab. Mutual fund investors should keep in mind that these costs apply only to some funds. Both brokers offer a long list of mutual funds that can be traded with no transaction fee.
thumb_down_off_alt Cons
There's no cryptocurrency trading at Schwab. Schwab's fractional shares, which they call “Stock Slices,” are limited to S&P 500 companies. Though this should satisfy most fractional share investors, other brokers offer many more choices.
Insurance coverage
Money market funds and other securities held in the Vanguard Brokerage Account are eligible for SIPC coverage. Securities in your brokerage account are protected up to $500,000. To learn more, visit the SIPC's website. Up to $250,000 by FDIC insurance.
You can start investing in securities by opening a Schwab brokerage account. You'll also get 24/7 support and a $0 account minimum.
That's because of Charles Schwab's huge banking business that generates revenue from sweep accounts, which are when the firm uses money leftover in investors' portfolios and reinvests it in securities, like government bonds, to help turn a profit.
What would happen if Vanguard went bust?
The securities that underlie the funds are held by a custodian, not by Vanguard. Vanguard is paid by the funds to provide administration and other services. If Vanguard ever did go bankrupt, the funds would not be affected and would simply hire another firm to provide these services.
Vanguard is owned by its funds, which in turn, are owned by their shareholders. With no other parties to answer to and therefore no conflicting loyalties, Vanguard makes decisions, including the decision to keep investing costs as low as possible, with clients' interests in mind.
Full Charles Schwab broker review. This stock broker is a good fit for: Investors seeking a one-stop-shop brokerage solution. Charles Schwab's commissions, investment options, and array of account offerings (investing and banking) make it a clear top pick to consider.
In response to its China investments, the Financial Times reported that the nonprofit group Coalition for a Prosperous America criticized Vanguard for "acting as a pipeline through which US investment dollars are being funneled into Chinese military companies and corporations sanctioned over human rights abuses."
When the market cratered, investors withdrew $16.4 billion from Vanguard's index mutual funds. What accounts for remaining index mutual fund outflows? Johnson says it could be clients pulling out money because they're retiring, or because they're negatively affected by the pandemic.
All investing is subject to risk, including the possible loss of money you invest. For more information about Vanguard mutual funds or ETFs, obtain a mutual fund or ETF prospectus or, if available, a summary prospectus.
Is Charles Schwab better than Vanguard? After testing 18 of the best online brokers, our analysis finds that Charles Schwab (96.6%) is better than Vanguard (80.3%).
After testing 18 of the best online brokers, our analysis finds that Fidelity (98.7%) is better than Charles Schwab (96.6%). Fidelity is a value-driven online broker offering $0 trades, industry-leading research, excellent trading tools and an easy-to-use mobile app.
One of the key factors that set Charles Schwab Corporation apart from its competitors was its focus on providing low-cost, accessible investment options for everyday investors. Schwab believed that everyone should have the opportunity to invest in the stock market, not just the wealthy elite.
From August 2022 through March 2023, Charles Schwab lost deposits due to client cash sorting at a pace of $5.6 billion per month as yields on savings accounts or other safe short-term assets like certificates of deposits rose. These deposit outflow pressures slowed significantly following the regional banking crisis.
Should I keep my money in Charles Schwab?
Yes, in addition to SIPC, Schwab clients receive an extra level of coverage through "excess SIPC" insurance protection for securities and cash. This helps ensure claims will be covered in the event of a brokerage firm failure and funds covered by SIPC protections are exhausted.
What if no buyer emerges and Schwab must be liquidated? Your investments are likely still safe as brokerage firms are required to keep their customers' securities and cash segregated from their own. This is to ensure that even if a brokerage company fails, its customers' assets will be safe.
So, what if Vanguard's brokerage fails? First, the chances of Vanguard failing are miniscule. That said, let's talk about brokerage accounts for a minute. Brokerage accounts are not backed by the FDIC but by the Securities Investor Protection Corp (SIPC), which protects accounts up to $500,000.
If there's a pending fee in any of your Vanguard accounts, this could prevent the withdrawal from being sent. Or if you change your nominated bank account after submitting a withdrawal. You can also choose to withdraw when you sell your holdings if you have a nominated and verified bank account.
There are a couple of reasons this may happen: it can take a few days for the cash to clear in your account, and if you've chosen funds already, for the transaction to complete and show in your account. we may need some more documents from you.
